Tharisa – ridiculously cheap, High Rhodium Price means a likely PE well under 4

In recent months I have been investing more in natural resource co’s. Focussing on Uranium (URNM, KAP, YCA (now sold for more URNM). I bought copper via COPM and CAML as well as gold/ silver via metals holdings and AAZ (free mines following the Azerbaijan/Armenia war) as well as TSG and a few others….

Now my portfolio is c48% natural resources with 10% gold/ silver metal. I bought Tharisa a few weeks ago to add to this replacing my holding in JLP, as I think this is better…

There has been disruption in production due to COVID , but the main reason I am in is (in the main) due to developed world money printing. I believe this will be inflationary so resources that can’t be printed are a good place to be. Think about it like this, if the stock of money increases (say) 25% then any fixed quantity in the economy should also increase by at least this. Of course, reality is not that simple as demand/ production increases / decreases. I believe this printing is not like that which occurred around 2010 as that was to recapitalise the banks so just sat on their balance sheets so wasn’t inflationary whereas this will get out into the ‘real’ economy.

Coupled with this Mining has been an out of favour sector since the early 2010s arguably before. This chart on mining investment arguably proves the point, though its hard to get definitive figures.

Recently there have been price rises in a number of metals, particularly Tin, Rhodium, Copper. It’s difficult to know if this will be sustained, is it under-investment catching up with the world, a covid induced spike or speculation-related? I don’t know but I suspect it is a mix of all 3. If the world had plenty of resources we wouldn’t be seeing these wide spikes.

Rhodium is used in catalytic converters to convert Nitrogen Oxide in car exhaust gases to reduce smog. China (amongst other countries) has recently mandated stricter emissions standards which is likely to lead to increased demand. It can be worked around (somewhat) by reengineering the catalytic converters but this is not easy to do and manufacturer’s have been hit by emissions scandals so will be very careful in doing this, only small amounts are in each converter. Supply seems very stable, at prices <800 oz ( until recently) there isn’t much incentive to develop new mines.

Tharisa is interesting as it’s a platinum producer which has a production basket / likely future revenue as follows: (my estimates 2021 – highly dependent on the Rhodium price)

160000Oz
Revenue (M USD)
14.40%RU3858.9
4.30%IR600041.3
55.40%PT1163103.1
16.20%PD259367.2
9.50%Rh8000121.6
0.20%AU17380.6
There is also a 15% refining margin, company is looking at moving this in-house.

The 160000 Oz is from company projections (Link). Maybe they achieve this, maybe not. Crucial point is the rise in the rhodium price. This went from under $11600 in 2020 (average) to pushing $30k now.

Hard to say how long this lasts, but for as long as it does we get >$1.0 m (total)per day. That’s just on Rhodium. The difference between a $30’000 Rhodium price and a $8000 price is an extra c$330m a year in revenue, much of which will drop through to the bottom line. Of course we are only in March and don’t know exactly how long this will last / when exactly they are selling the Rhodium / exactly how much will be produced. My preference would be to forward sell and not risk a price fall, I believe the management thinks prices will go higher so won’t do this.

EDIT (23/3/2021 I got the basket wrong (now fixed) – mixing 3E. 6E up, Details used on Page 5 of the slide here. Basically this isnt the blog you want to be reading for detailed financial numbers, I am very much big picture, its still cheap.)

This company has a market cap of $546m, no debt. The share price is under double what it was in Feb last year and not much over 2019 highs. I believe it has been held back by institutional selling by Fidelity, they were at 9.87% in October, down to 4.9% now. It doesnt worry me too much why / if they have been selling. The mine has a life of 40 years with possibility for extension (p2) so it isn’t down to depletion.

And let’s not forget they also produce Chrome, which has also risen in price… Company states:

Average metallurgical grade chrome price for Q1 FY2021 of US$136/t (ZAR2 114/t), vs Q1 FY2020 of US$145/t (ZAR 2 120/t) and Q4 FY2020 of US$142/t (ZAR2 376/t). The current market price is US$145/t to US$150/t

https://www.londonstockexchange.com/news-article/THS/production-report-q1-fy2021/14822623

I recon they will make c$220m from Chrome. But don’t trust me on these numbers, I am not really into producing detailed forecasts. I prefer finding really cheap stocks where any idiot could make money, then being that idiot…

What concerns me more is the shareholding structure – they have a controlling 39.15% shareholder Medway, never a positive for me, I prefer a more balanced structure. They are buying an exploration asset from them, we will see if pricing is fair. There is a lack of free float here – possibly the cause of the opportunity but it equally means any rerating may be eye-wateringly rapid.

I am also concerned that this is South Africa based. I am not terribly happy about investing in resource rich countries where the ‘natives’ recently took charge. There is a tendency for these states to rapidly degenerate into kleptocracies. South Africa is showing many of these tendencies and is one of my least favourite countries to invest in. Still, this is cheap, if it was based in a ‘better’ country without such a large controlling shareholder I would be comfortable holding more.

I bought in at 136 recently at a 3% portfolio weight. Since my move to more mining co’s I have cut my individual stock weights considerably. It’s too easy for these stocks to have flooded mines, deaths geological mishaps so I want to manage my risk. I am heavily invested in an area which is pretty new to me so I want to be careful with each individual idea..

The upside on this even if we only have a few quarters of these high prices is significant. I believe we make a significant fraction of the market cap. If we fall back, to me, it’s likely the share price only falls 30/40%, at the very worst case with an upside far in excess of this if prices are maintained / rise. I believe the market is pricing this stock as if this is a *very* temporary spike in resource prices, when it may well not be.

7 thoughts on “Tharisa – ridiculously cheap, High Rhodium Price means a likely PE well under 4”

  1. Hi Rob, Enjoyed your article and will do some follow up research. On the macro front the Federal Reserve and Central Banks cannot allow interest rates to rise significantly as levels of debt are too high. Publically they will declare they want to control inflation, but the only route they have is to inflate debt away. We will have low nominal interest rates and higher inflation giving negative real interest rates for years, which is ideal for rising valuations on real assets such as commodities. Additionally there is increasing demand for metals essential to the electrification of economies driven by decarbonisation. For copper I have read reports of 4% to 6% increase YOY in demand and it will take years for the supply side to respond. Like you I have been increasing investment in precious metals and decarbonisation metals. Rhodium is a special case and at this point I don’t know how easy it is to substitute, at what price substitution would occur and the time period over which this would occur, again some checking needed. I am convinced we are in the early stages of a strong bull market in most commodities.

  2. Thank you for very interesting take on Tharisa.

    Did you consider SLP as an alternative. I hold SLP and have done since Nov 2019 and showing a tidy profit and with a consensus price of 200p target (for what they are worth) still has a good upside (though my gains aren’t what they could have been as I sold a chunk in my March meltdown).

    Looking at them side by side there seems little to choose between them but as I feel I “know” SLP quite well my inclination is to stick with it.

    Regards

    Michael.

  3. I top sliced part of my SLP holding into Tharisa as they are very similar and it reduces any potential liquidity problems.SLP has gone up 200% since i bought into them and if Rhodiums price keeps rising then it could easily go up another 900% or more. .SLP is quite liquid upto about £14K which is good for a small miner.
    Like Rob my main worry is the South African govt.The ‘safe’ African govts are:
    Botswana,Ghana,Kenya, Mauritius,Morocco,Senegal,,Zambia.
    Outside of those 7 one needs the type of compelling investment case that SLP and Tharisa have to get involved

  4. What I don’t like about Tharisa is the chart. It trades at a 5 year high. I would prefer to buy at maximum pessimism.

    1. I see your point, I dont like the chart much either but when something is this cheap on the numbers I am happy to buy on a high. I tend to want the price to start moving before I buy in regardless….

  5. The argument with inflation may be a bit short-sighted. Companies can also increase their sales if inflation increases. Their costs (mainly staff costs) do not necessarily have to rise.
    However, the capital cycle supports commodity prices by reducing supply when prices are low.
    However, commodity prices have already gone up. So not sure if this still works.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s